The roots of Somalia instability stretch deep into the country’s post-independence history, shaped by colonial legacies, authoritarian rule, clan rivalries, civil war, and foreign interventions. While Somalia once held promise as a unified and ethnically homogenous state in the Horn of Africa, decades of internal conflict and external interference have left it fragmented and fragile. Understanding how Somalia descended into prolonged instability requires a careful examination of the events, decisions, and power struggles that unraveled the state from within.
Colonial Legacy and the Birth of Somalia (Pre-1960 to 1969)
Modern Somalia was formed in 1960 through the union of two former colonies: British Somaliland in the north and Italian Somaliland in the south. Upon independence, the new Somali Republic was heralded as one of Africa’s more promising nations due to its ethnic and linguistic homogeneity. Despite these commonalities, internal clan structures remained deeply entrenched.
Somalia’s first years were governed under a democratic parliamentary system. However, systemic corruption, clan favoritism, and political paralysis began to erode trust in democratic institutions. The fragile democracy was cut short in 1969 when President Abdirashid Ali Shermarke was assassinated. Shortly after, Major General Mohamed Siad Barre staged a bloodless coup, establishing a military regime.
Read Also: South Sudan War: Ethnic Strife, Power Struggles, and a Forgotten Crisis
Siad Barre’s Regime and Cold War Politics (1969–1991)
Siad Barre’s government adopted a Marxist-Leninist ideology, promoting scientific socialism and secularism while attempting to suppress clan loyalties in favor of Somali nationalism. The regime made early gains in education and infrastructure, including an ambitious literacy campaign. However, power was increasingly centralized in Barre’s hands, and political dissent was ruthlessly crushed.
During the Cold War, Somalia first aligned with the Soviet Union and received extensive military aid. The alliance broke down after Somalia’s failed invasion of Ethiopia’s Ogaden region in 1977, in a bid to unite ethnic Somalis across borders. When the Soviet Union backed Ethiopia instead, Barre turned to the United States, which provided military and economic aid throughout the 1980s.
Internally, Barre increasingly relied on his own Marehan clan and marginalized others. This favoritism and the regime’s brutality—especially the genocidal campaign against the Isaaq clan in the north—sowed the seeds of rebellion. Armed opposition groups like the Somali National Movement (SNM) and the United Somali Congress (USC) gained traction in the late 1980s.
Read Also: The Ongoing DRC Conflict: Causes, Impacts, and Possible Solutions
State Collapse and the Warlord Era (1991–2000)
In January 1991, Siad Barre was ousted by a coalition of rebel factions. His fall, however, marked not the beginning of peace, but the total collapse of Somalia’s central government. Rival warlords, most notably General Mohamed Farrah Aidid and Ali Mahdi Mohamed, vied for control of Mogadishu, turning the capital into a battleground.
The central government disintegrated. With no functioning state apparatus, Somalia became a patchwork of clan-controlled territories. Widespread famine and human suffering caught the attention of the international community. The United Nations and the United States intervened under humanitarian missions such as Operation Restore Hope (1992–1993). However, clashes with local militias, particularly the infamous Battle of Mogadishu in 1993, led to a hasty U.S. withdrawal after 18 American soldiers were killed and their bodies dragged through the streets. The UN also pulled out in 1995, having failed to stabilize the country.
Read Also: Yemen Houthi War: Origins, Timeline, and Current State of the Yemeni Civil War
The Rise of Islamic Movements and Al-Shabaab (2000–2010)
Amid lawlessness, local Islamic courts began emerging in the late 1990s to provide justice and basic governance. These courts eventually unified under the Islamic Courts Union (ICU), which gained broad public support and captured Mogadishu in 2006. Their success in restoring order was viewed positively by many Somalis.
However, the ICU’s rise triggered alarm in Ethiopia and the United States, who feared an Islamist takeover that could turn Somalia into a terrorist haven. With U.S. backing, Ethiopia invaded in late 2006, toppling the ICU and reinstating the weak Transitional Federal Government (TFG). The invasion fueled resentment and led to the emergence of Al-Shabaab, a radical offshoot of the ICU.
Al-Shabaab launched a brutal insurgency and rapidly gained control over large swathes of southern Somalia. The group imposed a harsh interpretation of Sharia law and began launching suicide bombings and terrorist attacks both within Somalia and in neighboring countries such as Kenya and Uganda. Their presence severely undermined TFG efforts to re-establish control.
Fragmentation and Regional Autonomy
While southern Somalia was embroiled in conflict, the north experienced a different trajectory. Somaliland, which had briefly existed as an independent nation in 1960 before unification, declared independence again in 1991. Though not internationally recognized, Somaliland has maintained relative peace, a functioning government, and regular elections.
Puntland, another semi-autonomous region in the northeast, chose federalism over full secession. It has experienced occasional conflicts but remains more stable than the south. These two regions illustrate that localized governance, when clan and community structures are respected, can offer a measure of stability—even without international recognition.
Read Also: The Real Causes of Somalia Instability
Attempts at Rebuilding and Ongoing Challenges (2012–Present)
In 2012, a new Federal Government of Somalia (FGS) was established with international backing, replacing the transitional government. The African Union Mission in Somalia (AMISOM) played a major role in pushing Al-Shabaab out of Mogadishu and other urban centers. Turkey, Qatar, the UAE, and other countries began investing in Somali reconstruction and infrastructure.
Despite these improvements, challenges remain immense. Al-Shabaab continues to control rural areas and stages regular attacks in cities, including bombings in Mogadishu. The federal government struggles to extend its authority beyond the capital. Political infighting, corruption, and disputes between the central government and federal member states hinder effective governance.
Clan rivalries persist, and many Somalis still feel excluded from national political processes. Efforts to hold one-person-one-vote elections have been repeatedly delayed. Foreign influence remains a double-edged sword—providing necessary aid and training, but also entrenching divisions through proxy rivalries.
Somalia’s current instability is the result of a long, complex unraveling of the state. The seeds were sown during the colonial era, and post-independence leaders failed to build inclusive institutions. Siad Barre’s authoritarian rule and Cold War maneuvering alienated large segments of society, setting the stage for civil war. The ensuing power vacuum led to warlordism, failed international interventions, and the rise of extremist groups.
The disintegration of Somalia into a patchwork of semi-autonomous regions, militant-controlled zones, and weak federal institutions is the result of a long history of misgovernance, foreign interventions, and unresolved clan tensions. Although efforts have been made to restore order and rebuild the nation, Somalia instability continues to threaten peace and development. Lasting stability will only be achieved through inclusive governance, national reconciliation, and strengthened institutions that address the complex legacy of Somalia’s fractured past.
